This is the time of year when the Grand Debate begins again in earnest (I know it never really goes away – let’s just say it simmers for the rest of the year): whether to buy a real Christmas tree or a fake one. Of course, once you’ve opted for the fake, you are more or less tied into that choice for the next few years, if only to justify the expenditure. But the Debate continues, even so; the real tree fanatics never let go.

Personally, I am a devotee of the fake tree. It’s easy to put up, doesn’t drop pine needles all over the place, it looks just as good as the real thing and is even easier to take down again after the main event has faded into the distance. But I recognize that the most telling objection of the real tree fans is valid: the fake doesn’t have that wonderful pine tree smell.

Some things have to be sacrificed for convenience, however; if you really need that pine tree smell, go outside and smell a tree.

Whatever your preference, Kelli B. Grant of SmartMoney dot com has good advice for buying either type of tree. If you still haven’t decided which type to go for, she could help make up your mind.